WCF. I. Of the Holy Scriptures - 2-5. Q & A

Blogging through the questions from G. I. Williamson's The Westminster Confession of Faith for Study Classes.

Prior post: I. Of the Holy Scriptures - 1.

WCF. I. Of the Holy Scriptures - 2-5.

1. What is the "proof" that the Bible is inspired?

     Evidence both internal and external to God's Word is "proof" that the Bible is inspired. The internal evidence claims it is the Word of God, the New Testament authors believed the Old Testament was inspired, Jesus Christ promised to give his Holy Scripture to his disciples in order to write the New Testament Scriptures (see John 14:26), within the New Testament we see that the different authors treat each others writings as the inspired Word of God, the Bible contains information that could only be revealed (e.g., Creation, the future new heaven and new earth), in addition, the Bible contains many prophesies that were fulfilled. The "external evidence is subordinate, but important" (7): the Church in all ages has acknowledge Scripture as inspired, and the Scriptures have "been preserved as no other writing on earth" (7), indicating God's special care.

2. How does the Bible express the claim that it is inspired?

     The Bible claims to be the word of God. The Bible claims God is its author.

3. Why cannot the authority of the Bible depend on the "testimony" of any man or Church?

     The authority of the Bible cannot depend on the "testimony" of any man or Church because both can and oftentimes err. "Yet it is no small thing that the Church even in its darkest days has acknowledged that the Bible is the Word of God" (7).

4. What is Rome's audacious claim?

     Rome's audacious claim is that the the Bible is the Word of God, but that this certainty depends upon the testimony of the Church. (See the Baltimore Catechism, Q. 1327: "it is only from Tradition (preserved in the Catholic Church) that we can know which of the writings of ancient times are inspired and which are not inspired.")

5. How do Protestants sometimes subordinate the authority of Scripture to men?

     This occurs when Protestants foolishly grant or give credence to the unbeliever's claim that there is nothing within Scripture that warrants them to believe it is the Word of God. That is, when Protestants grant that there is a "neutral" starting point from which to dive into the complex web of data (i.e., archaeological, historical, etc.) and attempt to sift through the facts and arrive at the truth of the matter. This is foolishness because it is idolatrous, it makes the reason of man the measure of all things.

6. Where must the evidence of Scripture's divinity be sought?

      The evidence must be sought in the Divine-Word; the evidence is evident in the intrinsic qualities. The Word of God is there. It is and in it are the evidences of its divinity. "As Prof. John Murray puts it: 'The authority of Scripture is an objective and permanent fact residing in the quality of inspiration'"(8).

7. If the evidence is there, why does not faith always result when men are confronted with that evidence?

     There is no deficiency in the evidence, so the reasons faith does not always result when men are confronted with the evidence is because "not all men have the requisite perceptive faculty" (8). What is the state of the man's heart? If they hate God, if the grace of God is not active in their heart, then their understanding is darkened by bondage to sin. The truth (evidence) is there, but they attempt to hold it down and suppress it (see Romans 1:18).

8. When the Confession speaks of the Holy Spirit "bearing witness," does it mean that the new truth conveyed to the mind?

     No. The Holy Spirit is not conveying new truth to the mind of man. The Holy Spirit "bearing witness" does so "by and with the word in our hearts." There is both the objective witness of Scripture and the internal testimony of the Holy Spirit, and man through the internal work of the Holy Spirit responds appropriately to the truth that is the objective witness of Scripture. The truth in the Bible is the truth conveyed to the mind of believers through the work of the Holy Spirit. "God's whole truth to man is contained in Scripture" (8). The Word of God is inherently perfect, therefore, the Holy Spirit does not convey new truth to the mind of man.